This was a story I wrote about 7 years ago and recently revisited. I decided it was about time to revise it and post it, again. Enjoy.
A BEAUTIFUL DECONSTRUCTION
by Jonathan Evans
Someone told me once – I cannot remember who – that all love is unrequited.
I have always wondered if that was true.
Part of me never wanted to believe it was “true.” Part of me wanted to believe that love meant something and that somewhere, someone, would see it and return it. However, as I grew up, my idealism for this perception of love faded and I came to accept the facts about love:
All love goes unnoticed and unwanted.
I truly believed this too, until the day I met Jenny.
Jenny Thurman was a girl, no, she was a woman and to me she was gorgeous. She was not your standout-type of beauty, but to me she was everything I had ever wanted. We first met one day while waiting for a class, an art class, I think.
You see we were both students at State College.
She was a marine biology major and I was a psychology major. How we both came to be taking an art class, who knows? I guess it looked fun.
To cut to the chase, you could say we hit it off as “friends” instantaneously, as if we had known each other for years. You might think that weird, but that was the truth. It was kind of, as if you had caught up on a lifetime of memories in just a few short weeks. Again, realistically this seems absurd, but it happens and whatever the bends in the space-time-continuum that were made, oh well. All of this made me believe that such things as kindred spirits and soul mates; stuff I had never given much thought to before this. As for Jenny and I, those first few weeks was just like several lifetimes…I wished it could have never ended…
However, like all things, good things too run out and you have to change sides of the tape.
About one month after we met, things changed…in a big way. The main change came in how I felt for Jenny. For the last week of the “good times,” I had begun to struggle with what, for me, were strange emotions that I felt for Jenny. This was more than the kind you have for a friend…this was more, I could feel it.
How much more you might ask?
Time would tell, and I will tell of it.
Trying not to psychoanalyze and freak myself out, I attempted to bury those feelings in a deep dark place of my mind. I tried to forget about them. Yet, sometimes you can never bury things deep enough.
One night Jenny came over to my apartment to watch movies and to hang out. Before long, Jenny (who was tired from work) fell asleep on me – literally, on me. It was not a bad thing, I did not mind one bit personally, why would I? Not wanting to wake her, I rested her head on my lap and let her use me as a pillow. Unfortunately, the side effect of this was that I was now stuck…
Go ahead and laugh.
Yes, that’s right. Those feelings I was having…yes.
Listen to the sound of my emotions as they slam into a brick wall.
This was me, on the inside. On the outside, I simply sat there and watched TV while she slept. Every once and a while, when Jenny would stir, I would look down at her sleeping face and watch her for a time. It was during these moments, these little bits of in-betweens, while Jenny slept there peacefully that my “feelings” flooded back on me, like a tidal wave. Right then, at one of those moments, one of those “in-betweens,” as the waves of my emotions poured over me, as my emotions slammed into the brick wall, I realized what I felt for her.
I was in love with Jenny.
Now, let me digress. At this juncture, a normal person, one with some experience, would simply tell the girl/woman how they felt and ask her if she felt it in return. Then you just let the dice role and see what happens.
What did I do?
With all my vast storehouse of relationship experience…that was empty.
Nothing.
I did absolutely NOTHING.
“What the hell?” some people might ask when you hear that.
Well, let me try to explain my logic. Let me explain the little I can, because some of this was just completely born from naivety. There was one big problem.
Jenny had a boyfriend.
He was in the military and was not around a lot but that is not the point, she still had a boyfriend. However, despite this, as she lay there sleeping peacefully in my lap, I felt closer to her than I ever thought I could be to any other person. With these thoughts on my mind, these emotions sloshing around inside my heart, I somehow managed to fall to sleep that night.
The next morning Jenny apologized for “inconveniencing” me the night before. I told her it was alright and not to worry about it. After a few awkward moments, in which I more than likely should have realized was an opportunity to speak up and say something, Jenny left to go back to her own place and get cleaned up (her boyfriend was coming in that night to see her).
Right after she left me I felt a “ping” of jealously surge through me for Jenny. I tried to let it go, to distract myself the rest of the day in hopes of getting all of this out of my heart and off my mind. I did not work at all. Later on that night, while Jenny was probably out somewhere having a great time, I got drunk instead and passed out on my sofa around 11 PM.
Over the following couple of weeks, Jenny and I continued to hang out regularly and remained close. I continued to hide my emotions and feelings for her while trying to remain a good friend to her at the same time. I tried hard to keep things from being awkward or weird, though I think there were times she might have caught on (though she never openly showed it). There were times I think she truly saw past my façade but she never confronted me on it, so it all just continued at a “status quo.”
Some of my other friends were not so casual about dismissing the changes in me that they saw. They saw through my façade, they saw my increased drinking, and they saw my mood changes when Jenny would leave.
I think they could see my pain.
Even my teacher’s started noticing changes in me; a couple pulled me aside and talked to me about my slipping grades, always asking “Was I okay?”
Of course, I always played it off and gave them some excuse.
I knew how to answer the question.
When someone asked me, “Was I okay?”, my answer was “Yeah, I’m okay.”
I lied, a lot with that one.
However, soon those who cared about me most began to increasingly question me about my drinking and tried to stop me from spiraling out, but they could not stop it.
Only I could, and I no longer cared.
There was one area of my life during this time that I actually became more productive in, poetry. It was my outlet for all the emotional pains and turmoil I was putting myself through. My poems were the only doorway through which my tattered emotions found form or took any rational shape. They were the bearers of my secret love; they were a glimpse of into my hearts aching and desperation.
Almost poetic, those last lines, right?
Yeah, pure torture when the audience you want will never read them.
After about three and a half weeks of this “spiraling out,” Jenny brought the issue out into the open. Though it was as indirect as you can get, she simply asked me directly, “Was I okay?”
Ah, that familiar question I was getting used to at this point – lying about my answer at least.
Of course, I gave her the standard answer, the lie: “Yeah, I’m okay…just tired.”
I was lying of course, again.
For a moment, I saw in her eyes that she did not believe me, but she quickly changed the subject and moved on. She confided in me some problems her boyfriend and her were having…Agh! Somebody could have bludgeoned me right then. I simply listened and played the “good friend” for her instead. Here’s where it gets even worse: next, I attempted to help her find a way to resolve the problem and give her some advice to help. The only way to describe how I felt afterward was to say it felt like I was stabbing myself in the heart… poetic?
All of this continued on and on, like a sick cycle of torture for myself. One minute I would be with Jenny and be okay or happy, then she would leave and I slumped into a miserable depression.
It was like a roller-coaster, when you’re sick and you want to puke your guts out.
The only consistent thing in my life, at this time, was my ever-increasing crutch of alcohol. Friends soon began to get worried and they would pull me aside more and more to try to get me to quit all of this (the drinking, the misery, the depression…the whole bit).
As if I really had control over it…or did I?
I no longer knew.
I could not tell anymore.
I would listen to them and then never follow through. I was getting good at that too. I was in love…at least I think I was, and my life was falling apart all around me for it. It was a beautiful deconstruction. It was my little mini-meltdown that I wished did not belong to me. I am quite sure it could have passed for modern art though.
You might look at this little cycle of mine and think it could go on and on forever, as long as I let it, or until someone interfered (Jenny, my friends, anybody). Then again, I was human, how much longer could it go on until I just fell to pieces.
Well, someone did end it, but it was not someone I expected, it was Jenny’s boyfriend.
I think he had been suspicious of me, maybe jealous even of how much time we spent together, for a good while. I think he disapproved of how close we were and the time we spent hanging out. So, he did something about it finally…he called me. It was one of those awkward phone calls between two people who really do not know one another, or even like one another. The call was filled with the two us dancing around the subject. There was a lot of innuendo and hints, but I got the message loud and clear…
”You Need to Stay Away from Jenny!”
I got the message and the next day I made plans to start distancing myself from Jenny. I did not want any trouble for either of us and I thought this would be easier, if only for me. However, Jenny was of another mind on this altogether. She was an obstacle I did not count on and every move I made to back away, she just moved closer. I quickly realized that her boyfriend had acted independently, so I did nothing to stop her and the cycle simply continued, but it had changed. The change was Jenny’s boyfriend. He would increasingly and periodically show up and “interfere,” making me uneasy and sometimes even jealous.
Jenny and I both had a passion for 80’s music. There is one song that really began to spell out my current situation to me.
Can you guess which one?
Well, it’s not to difficult – “Jessie’s Girl” by Rick Springfield.
The song fit me so well that I really started to hate hearing it. It was like having someone spell out my self-destruction for me…in a song.
Self-destruction, now that was the name of my game now in truth. My frustration became ever more physical and manifested itself in me physically punching walls and total loss of temper over little things. Friends began to become so worried for me that they told my parents of my behavior to see if there was anything they could do. That really pissed off, but in hindsight I understood that they did because they cared about me, at the time though, I resented it and isolated myself even more.
The summation of my life was truly a self-made, self-destruction: I was failing classes, drinking heavily, becoming increasingly self-abusive, depressed, and was in love with a girl whom I had no idea whether she felt anything in return.
In general: I was fucked up.
I still did not know how Jenny felt, but I knew I could never tell her.
I had no right… I did not even know if I even wanted to. I simply wanted her to be happy, even if it meant without me, even if it meant my pain. I wanted to run away and hide from her in the hopes that it would end, but how can one run away from what makes them happy? It was the worse kind of pain, one that ate at me slowly…slowly, breaking me apart, brick by brick.
Then one night, it all changed again.
One night…one night, that is all it took to bring it all down. After months of hurt and slow, monotonous pain, it found an ending.
At around 7 PM, just as I was pouring the first shot of the evening, I got a call from Jenny. She was upset and crying to the point of being practically incoherent. Springing into my usual “good friend” mode, I was well rehearsed by now, I told her to stay where she was (at her apartment) and that I was coming over.
As I pulled up to her apartment, I saw a strange car in front of her place. My first guess was that it was her boyfriend’s.
I braced myself for a shit storm, got out of my car, and walked to her door.
Jenny answered, her eyes swollen and red from crying, her face was flush. It looked to me as if someone had slapped her across her face, my heartbeat jumped, anticipating a confrontation.
I asked her if someone had slapped her and she shied away from the question.
She didn’t have to say it; I knew the answer was “yes.”
I also knew who did it, her boyfriend.
As I examined Jenny, making sure she was okay, her boyfriend came through the door to her bedroom behind her. He yelled at me to get away from her, he reached over and pushed me away from Jenny. Then he turned to Jenny and accused her openly of cheating on him with me. He said he knew she liked me and that while he was away she spent time with me for that very reason.
As he shouted at her, he jerked her arm, throwing her around like a doll. I yelled back at him, told him to stop hurting her, he just ignored me. When I tried to grab him, to make him stop, he turned quickly and hit me. The force knocked me back to the floor.
Sitting there, I looked up at Jenny. I could see she wanted to help me, but she was afraid and her boyfriend was in the way.
She managed to blurt out “Don’t hurt him!”
Her boyfriend then turned and raised his hand to hit her.
As he did, I leaped from my place on the floor and grabbed his arm. Then, with my free hand, I clocked him…knocking him across the room and into the arm of the sofa.
As he lay there in shock, Jenny looked at me in confusion and shock at what at just happened.
It was then that I finally just spilled it all out, let it all go, and told Jenny everything.
What great timing I have.
Then again, I did not have anything left to lose at this point.
I looked at Jenny and said the words that had been in my heart and on my mind for months now: “I love you.”
I went on to say how long I had wanted to be with her, to say those words to her. I told her why I had not said something sooner and that I really wanted her just to be happy. I told her every detail, explained it all the best I could while tears began to come from my eyes.
When I was done, hearing no response from her in return, only blank looks of shock on Jenny’s face, as well as her boyfriend’s, I said my peace. I told her that if he (her boyfriend) made her happy, then she should be with him. I told him that she never cheated on him. I had never been with her, no matter how bad I wanted to. I told him that since I was a problem, I would make it easy on him and leave, they would never hear from me again.
At that, I left Jenny’s apartment and walked out of Jenny’s life.
Walking away I began to feel sick, like I was dying and I began to cry harder. I took my sweet time getting back to my apartment; I took as many detours as I could find.
When I did arrive back at my place, I got out of my car and slowly I walked toward my apartment.
When I got there though, I was shocked to find Jenny was waiting for me.
She was sitting there in front of my door, tears still on her cheeks, waiting for me to return. Without saying a word, Jenny got up and walked over to me. Putting her arms around me, she embraced me.
We stood there for a while, just like that, in each other’s arms without saying a word. I finally broke the silence; I asked Jenny why she was here? Her answer was as short as it was surprising:
She was here because she was in love with me too. Then she kissed me and time felt as if it simply stood still.
After a while, we both decided to go inside and sat down on my couch where Jenny told me more. She told me how she had known for a while, how I felt, she had read my poems and been paying attention to me more than I had realized. Before I could ask why she had not said something, she told me she had been confused and hoped maybe it would just go away. She said that had been wrong of her and recently she had discovered that the reason she was confused was that she loved me back. She too had hidden it from me. We both apparently had been mishandling this whole thing, but that was now over. Tonight she had realized her feelings and mine deserved better than silence. We both hugged each other and kissed. Sitting there in each other’s arms, we talked for hours until we fell asleep…right there in each other’s arms.
Epilogue:
My beautiful deconstruction had stripped me down until I was nothing, but only then could I build myself back up again; build myself back better than before. Only then was I able to find what love really was and find happiness without false pretenses. I now know that not all love is unrequited, sometimes it finds you and shows you that it did notice.